- Posted November 21, 2014
- Tweet This | Share on Facebook
Judge says emergency manager suit can proceed
By Ed White
Associated Press
DETROIT (AP) - Critics of Michigan's emergency manager law can challenge it as discrimination against blacks, a judge said Wednesday in allowing a lawsuit to move forward against an extraordinary tool used by Gov. Rick Snyder to try to fix the finances of poor cities and schools.
U.S. District Judge George Caram Steeh swept aside most of the lawsuit. But he said opponents at this early stage of the case have made a "plausible" claim that the law could violate the U.S. Constitution by having a disproportionate impact on communities with large black populations.
When the lawsuit was filed earlier this year, attorneys said 52 percent of Michigan's black residents were living in communities with emergency managers or strict financial oversight from the state. Most were in Detroit.
The law "confers enormous discretion to state decision-makers and creates a significant potential for discriminatory decisions," Steeh said.
Emergency managers have exceptional power to run local governments and school districts, while elected officials typically are pushed aside for 18 months or more.
Steeh's 39-page ruling was released seven months after he heard arguments. The case was allowed to proceed at that time only after the plaintiffs agreed it wouldn't affect Detroit's bankruptcy.
Snyder appointed Kevyn Orr as Detroit's emergency manager in March 2013. Four months later, they decided that bankruptcy was the best solution to get rid of billions of dollars of debt. On Nov. 7, a judge approved the city's plan to get out of bankruptcy.
Lawyers for the plaintiffs did not immediately return messages seeking comment. Snyder spokesman Dave Murray said race has no role in the law, which is formally known as Public Act 436.
It is "designed to be an objective measure of the financial health of a municipality or school district," he said.
Michigan voters overturned Snyder's first emergency manager law in the 2012 election. But he and fellow Republicans in the Legislature came back with another version just weeks later.
Flint, Hamtramck, Lincoln Park, Detroit schools, Highland Park schools and Muskegon Heights schools have emergency managers. Ten other local governments or school districts are under some type of oversight under the same law.
During arguments in April, Assistant Attorney General Michael Murphy denied that the law targeted blacks.
"The only color we're dealing with here is green - it's cash," Murphy said.
Published: Fri, Nov 21, 2014
headlines Oakland County
- Associations gather for Spring Fling
- Law school’s team wins William and Mary Colonial Cup Competition
- Supreme Court makes it easier to sue for job discrimination over forced transfers
- Oakland County Physician bound over on insurance fraud charges
- Innocence Project leaders present at University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School Spring Symposium
headlines National
- Incarceration series includes female inmates but doesn’t tell full story
- ACLU and BigLaw firm use ‘Orange is the New Black’ in hashtag effort to promote NY jail reform
- Former DOJ official who alleged election fraud violated at least one ethics rule, ethics committee says
- Winston & Strawn will provide reduced-cost legal services for routine tasks under Winston Legal Solutions umbrella
- Should Justice Sotomayor retire? Chemerinsky, White House haven’t joined calls for her to step down
- Which BigLaw firms are increasing lateral associate hiring the most? One made legal headlines last year