- Posted July 04, 2011
- Tweet This | Share on Facebook
Court rules schools can't pass union political cash
By Ed White
Associated Press
Public school districts cannot help unions by deducting political contributions from the paychecks of teachers, the Michigan Supreme Court said last Thursday as conservatives reversed a six-month-old ruling by liberal justices.
In a 4-3 decision, the court said public agencies cannot use their resources for political purposes, even if the Michigan Education Association reimburses schools for administering the payroll deduction. The case involved the Gull Lake district in Kalamazoo County.
"Monetary reimbursement, paid in advance or otherwise, is simply insufficient to recover the time that is diverted from the primary obligations of the school district," Justice Stephen Markman wrote.
The Supreme Court issued a completely different opinion in late December, just before Democrats lost their 4-3 majority. Republicans agreed to reconsider the case when they took control of the court.
"Instead of preserving precedent, this newly comprised majority reverses this court's previously issued opinion and issues its own opinion for no reason other than that it disagrees with the outcome of the prior opinion," said Justice Diane Hathaway in a dissent.
Justice Mary Beth Kelly, whose election in November tilted the court back to conservatives, said she could not let the previous decision stand.
"The opinion at issue was only days old when the composition of the court changed. ... Simply put, I would be derelict in my duty if I were to give deference to legal reasoning with which I find fault," Kelly wrote.
Justice Brian Zahra, who was appointed to the court in January, also put his name on Kelly's statement.
Published: Mon, Jul 4, 2011
headlines Oakland County
- Associations gather for Spring Fling
- Law school’s team wins William and Mary Colonial Cup Competition
- Supreme Court makes it easier to sue for job discrimination over forced transfers
- Oakland County Physician bound over on insurance fraud charges
- Innocence Project leaders present at University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School Spring Symposium
headlines National
- Incarceration series includes female inmates but doesn’t tell full story
- ACLU and BigLaw firm use ‘Orange is the New Black’ in hashtag effort to promote NY jail reform
- Former DOJ official who alleged election fraud violated at least one ethics rule, ethics committee says
- Winston & Strawn will provide reduced-cost legal services for routine tasks under Winston Legal Solutions umbrella
- Should Justice Sotomayor retire? Chemerinsky, White House haven’t joined calls for her to step down
- Which BigLaw firms are increasing lateral associate hiring the most? One made legal headlines last year