- Posted January 15, 2018
- Tweet This | Share on Facebook
Judge won't lift ban; recruit remains benched
By Ed White
Associated Press
DETROIT (AP) - A judge on last Thursday rejected a plea from a Michigan State basketball recruit who's been barred from playing his senior season after transferring to a new high school.
Thomas Kithier said his rights have been violated by the Michigan High School Athletic Association. But U.S. District Judge Marianne Battani said there's no constitutional right to play high school sports or participate in any school-related activity.
That may be a "shock to some," the judge said.
The MHSAA said Kithier is ineligible because his transfer to defending Class A champion Clarkston from Dakota was motivated by sports and a desire to play with another Michigan State recruit, Foster Loyer, who was his teammate on a summer team.
Kithier and his parents insist that he left Dakota because he wanted a better education. They turned to federal court after losing an appeal.
Battani said the law isn't on Kithier's side, even if he misses an "opportunity of a lifetime" by not playing a final year of high school basketball. The 18-year-old's attorney, Ven Johnson, described it as a "death penalty."
Kithier declined to comment on Battani's decision. Outside court, another attorney, Steve Fishman, said the MHSAA "screwed over a kid" who didn't do anything wrong.
During more than an hour of arguments, an attorney for the MHSAA said legal precedent weighed heavily in favor of the organization.
"The MHSAA's obligation is to enforce the rules as written. ... Courts don't opine on the wisdom of rules written by voluntary associations," attorney Scott Eldridge said.
Published: Mon, Jan 15, 2018
headlines Oakland County
- Meet the Judges
- Owner of twice-sunken Lake Michigan barge pleads guilty to felony
- Justice Dept. reaches civil settlement with victims abused by Lawrence Nassar
- Oakland County, Oakland Livingston Human Services Agency launch Oakland County Senior Chore Pilot Program
- U.S. Immigration Court judge to be keynote speaker at law school’s Law Day virtual celebration
headlines National
- New Legalese: You may have heard a deepfake, but what about ‘Twiqbal’?
- From Intake to Outcome: An in-house lawyer’s guide to matter management solutions
- 2 BigLaw firms in merger talks that could produce 1,600-lawyer firm with top 50 revenue
- Send in the paralegals
- Lawyer reprimanded after mistakenly emailing opposing counsel with plan to avoid judge’s call
- ‘I don’t play well’ judge who threatened to track down, jail misbehaving litigant gets tossed from case