- Posted September 22, 2011
- Tweet This | Share on Facebook
Lawsuit filed over kids tested for alcohol in park
LIVONIA (AP) -- Teens celebrating graduation from eighth grade in suburban Detroit were illegally forced to take breath tests after repeatedly denying they were drinking alcohol in the woods, the American Civil Liberties Union said Tuesday in a lawsuit against police.
Five students from Discovery Middle School in Canton Township passed the breath test during a picnic in June. The lawsuit says parents were not contacted ahead of the test nor did Livonia officers get a warrant.
An assistant principal found an empty liquor bottle in the woods and wrongly suspected trouble, the ACLU said.
"Federal and state courts have ruled over and over again that if a teen is not driving, the police need a search warrant to administer a breath test," said ACLU attorney Dan Korobkin. "When there is no evidence that a child has done anything wrong, he should never be subjected to this degrading and embarrassing procedure in front of his teachers and peers."
Livonia police and the Plymouth-Canton school district declined to comment.
The lawsuit against Livonia was filed in federal court on behalf of a 13-year-old boy. It seeks a financial award and removal of the boy's name from police records.
"My son has always been taught to respect his educators and law enforcement," the boy's mother, Tina Barbee, said in a statement. "In June, he was taught a very different lesson: educators and police make mistakes. Although a wrong was done, I truly believe it can be made right."
Published: Thu, Sep 22, 2011
headlines Oakland County
- Historical: Circuit Court judge has made indelible mark
- ABA amicus brief supports noncitizens’ right to a bond hearing when detention becomes ‘unreasonably prolonged’
- Nessel secures full victory in lawsuit challenging administration’s attack on fair housing protections
- Whitmer announces new automotive jobs, investment in Oakland County
- AG pushes federal government to strengthen rules to combat illegal robocalls
headlines National
- ABA Legal Ed council repeals DEI standard
- Is Perry Mason TV’s most effective lawyer? New study names top 5
- Lawyer who cited paraphrasing as direct quotes in 2nd Circuit brief says AI played a role
- After jury deadlock and mistrial, Lindsay Clancy could face second trial
- Murder, Corruption and RICO in Georgia: Fateful meeting I didn’t want to attend led to courtroom win
- Bad Bunny, Justin Bieber among musical stars facing copyright suit for using reggaeton’s signature beat




