Gongwer News Service
Attorney General Dana Nessel filed a lawsuit Thursday against the owners of Mackinac Island’s ferry operators, alleging an “unlawful monopoly” in the ferry service and long-term parking markets that serve the Island.
Nessel’s antitrust lawsuit (opens michigan.gov in a new tab), filed in the Ingham Circuit Court, alleges that the Hoffmann Family of Companies and its affiliates illegally monopolized the market as it took control of every passenger ferry line and commercial dock serving the island, as well as nearly all the long-term parking near the mainland ferry terminals.
Hoffmann, a Florida-based private equity firm led by billionaire David Hoffmann (opens forbes.com in a new tab), “bought up every inch of the Mackinac Island ferry service industry, and as a result of those acquisitions, a single company has come to control the market for ferry transportation to and from Mackinac Island,” Nessel told reporters Thursday.
There were once three ferry companies providing transportation to and from the Island – Shepler’s, Arnold and Star – but now Hoffmann owns all ferry service.
The island’s famed car-free status — dating back to a ban in 1898 — makes the ferries and long-term parking essential for residents and visitors alike.
The “concentration of market power raises serious antitrust concerns, including the exercise of monopoly power and the resulting harm to competition, consumers, businesses, and to the public,” Nessel said.
Nessel’s lawsuit, filed soon before she’s slated to leave office, came with a plea that state officials work to bolster antitrust regulations and enforcement. She also inserted the attorney general’s office into a broader battle over the Island’s ferry operations, one that she said she expects her successor to continue.
“I have discussed this” with Attorney General-elect Eli Savit, Nessel said Thursday, “and he’s fully on board, and he supports this litigation. And I think he’s in full-throated support of continuing this and making sure that we are again protecting the businesses and the people of Mackinac Island, as well as people all over the state and our country who wish to enjoy it.”
Savit on Thursday confirmed Nessel’s remarks and declined to comment further.
In response to the lawsuit, a spokesperson for the Hoffmann Family of Companies said Thursday, “We are aware of the lawsuit, are reviewing it, and will respond in court. We will defend ourselves and are confident we will prevail, because we are not violating state or federal antitrust laws.”
This lawsuit comes after Mackinac Island previously sued the ferry companies (opens woodtv.com in a new tab) in a federal court last year, alleging the companies were a monopoly because they were owned by the same parent company.
“As a reminder, the federal court has already twice rejected the City of Mackinac Island’s antitrust claims in its federal litigation against us,” the Hoffmann Family of Companies spokesperson said. That person pointed to Nessel’s statement from April of this year (opens michigan.gov in a new tab) that encouraged mediation between Mackinac Island and the ferry operator.
“We wholeheartedly agreed with her and are in active mediation,” the spokesperson said. “We believe this lawsuit threatens to derail those efforts.”
A federal judge dismissed the City of Mackinac Island’s lawsuit (opens woodtv.com in a new tab) earlier this year, saying the city lacked standing.
The state doesn’t have the same antitrust requirements, said Jonathan Comish, assistant attorney general, during Thursday’s news conference.
“We have the ability to bring a lawsuit against anyone who violates our antitrust laws just because they violated the laws,” he said.
Nessel’s lawsuit asks the court for relief to “restore competition,” including the potential divestiture of ferry and parking assets, “damages for the overcharges its residents paid for ferry service and parking,” and civil penalties.
This lawsuit marks the latest chapter in a long-running dispute over the Island’s ferry and parking services.
On Election Day, Mackinac Island voters approved a proposal (opens mlive.com in a new tab) to expand the city’s authority over ferry ticket prices and fees to park on the mainland.
––––––––––––––––––––
Subscribe to the Legal News!
https://www.legalnews.com/Home/Subscription
Full access to public notices, articles, columns, archives, statistics, calendar and more
Day Pass Only $4.95!
One-County $80/year
Three-County & Full Pass also available




