Gongwer News Service
Requirements that women wait 24 hours and receive uniform informed consent information before having an abortion are unconstitutional under the reproductive freedom amendment passed in 2022, the Court of Appeals unanimously ruled this week.
Northland Family Planning Center et. al. v. Attorney General Dana Nessel et. al. (Docket No. 375785 (opens courts.michigan.gov in a new tab)), a published decision released Wednesday, affirmed a 2025 Court of Claims decision in the case on informed consent, the 24-hour waiting period and the requirement that only a physician perform an abortion.
The unanimous decision, written by Judge Stephen Borrello and signed by Judge Mariam Bazzi and Judge Andrew Lievense, sent one issue back to the Court of Claims. Judge Sima Patel ruled a requirement to screen for the possibility the woman had been coerced into an abortion did not “deny, burden or infringe upon the fundamental right to reproductive freedom.”
Although the Court of Appeals panel found no error in Patel’s conclusion that the anti-coercion law, on its face, did not infringe upon the right to reproductive freedom, the judges called for a more thorough analysis.
“The statutory scheme at issue prohibits only coercion to abort, yet it fails to equally prohibit coercion to become pregnant or to continue a pregnancy. This legislative asymmetry may result in a statutory framework that, in practice, protects only one facet of the spectrum of reproductive autonomy. Such a statutory omission raises a significant constitutional question under the Equal Protection Clause of the Michigan Constitution,” Borrello wrote. “A law that proscribes coercion in one direction, but not the other, risks operating in a manner that discriminates against individuals who seek to exercise the full range of reproductive choices guaranteed by our Constitution.”
Patel’s ruling struck down laws requiring a 24-hour waiting period and uniform consent information. Patel also ruled a requirement that only physicians perform abortions was unconstitutional.
The Court of Appeals panel affirmed the ruling on the three statutes. For the waiting period and consent information, Borrello wrote both were arbitrary and inflexible in their application.
“The statute’s rigid, standardized framework ignores this reality, supplanting clinical judgment with a legislative mandate that may be irrelevant or even detrimental in particular cases,” he wrote about the required consent information. “This approach not only fails to enhance patient understanding but may actively obstruct the decision-making process by overwhelming patients with information that is immaterial or distressing.”
Borrello also wrote that the ban on nurse practitioners, certified nurse midwives and physician assistants from providing abortions “cannot withstand constitutional scrutiny and is invalid.”
Planned Parenthood of Michigan President and CEO Paula Thornton Greear called on the new Legislature to repeal the laws deemed unconstitutional when it convenes in January.
“Michigan voters decided that decisions about pregnancy belong to the person who is pregnant, and this ruling holds the state to that,” she said in a statement. “These laws had nothing to do with patient health, because they delayed care,
forced people to read state-written material no clinician would hand a patient for any other kind of care, and limited who could provide that care — and now the courts have said so twice.”
––––––––––––––––––––
Subscribe to the Legal News!
https://www.legalnews.com/Home/Subscription
Full access to public notices, articles, columns, archives, statistics, calendar and more
Day Pass Only $4.95!
One-County $80/year
Three-County & Full Pass also available




